• Harvest-dated EVOO

    Current-crush oils, never old stock

  • Balsamic from Modena

    Imported from Modena, Italy

  • Taste first, from $8

    Sample sizes on every flavor

  • 5-star Google rated

Nanny GOAT Olive Shop represents expert rated, fresh, extra virgin olive oils & balsamic vinegars

Explore our premium products today!

Shop Products

Welcome to Nanny GOAT Olive Shop, your destination for premium Extra Virgin Olive Oils and Balsamic Vinegars.
We take pride in partnering with exceptional producers to source, import, and craft the highest-quality gourmet products — bringing the taste of excellence right to your table.

EXTRA VIRGIN OLIVE OILS 

Expert rated, fresh, EVOO produced by top mills in
Northern Hemisphere

BALSAMIC VINEGARS

Our vinegars represents unique, traditional and innovative vinegars from Modena, Italy
Includes:  Dark - White Balsamic & Fruit Vinegars

CUSTOM GIFT BOXES 

Custom gift boxes designed for your unique occasion

ORDER NOW

Why home cooks trust Nanny GOAT

Fresh oil, honest sourcing, and a real person behind every bottle.

  • Harvest-dated EVOO

    Every extra virgin oil is labeled by crush year, sourced from expert-rated mills in the Northern Hemisphere.

  • Balsamic from Modena

    Dark, white and whole-fruit vinegars imported from Modena, Italy, home of balsamic.

  • Taste before you commit

    Sample sizes from $8 on every flavor, or build your own sample box.

  • Owner-run, market-tested

    Natalie pours and pairs every flavor herself at local markets and events.

Loved in local kitchens

What our customers are saying

★★★★★ 5.0 on Google
★★★★★
“You can taste the quality and care in every bottle. Shout out to Natalie for being one of the best.”
Shatica Miles
★★★★★
“We pair both with sourdough, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and basil. It’s soooo good!”
Duck Hollow Homestead
★★★★★
“Top ingredients and so flavorful! One of the best oils I have tried!”
Tina Perrone

PERFECT PAIRINGS

CUSTOMER TESTIMONIALS

Nanny Goat Olive Shop products have become a favorite in my kitchen. The balsamic and olive oils add depth, warmth, and real flavor to even simple meals. You can taste the quality and care in every bottle. Beyond the taste, there is something special about supporting someone who clearly loves what they create. Highly recommended. Shout out to Natalie for being one of the best.

Shatica Miles

We love Nanny Goat Olive Oil and Balsamic! We love to pair both of those with some sourdough, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and basil it’s soooo good! Highly recommend their Olive oils and Balsamics! Great flavor and taste!

Duck Hollow Homestead

Top ingredients and so flavorful! One of the best oils I have tried!

Tina Perrone

PLEASE JOIN US!